Barnaby is eighteen pounds of brown tabby Maine Coon with a tail like a feather duster and a habit of following me from room to room. He is eight now, and he has gotten a little stiff about jumping onto the bed. What he has not gotten is smaller. For years I scooped a standard pan that he hung over the edge of like a man in a too-small bathtub, and every morning I swept litter off the laundry room floor before I had my coffee. When I finally went looking for something bigger, I kept landing on two names: the IRIS USA XX-Large high-sided box, and a plain stainless steel pan. What follows is what I found living with the IRIS USA box and borrowing a friend's steel pan for a few weeks of honest comparison.

Short answer first. If your cat is long and tall and the mess comes from him hanging over the rim, the IRIS USA box solves the problem it was built for: thirty inches long, twenty wide, fourteen inches of wall, and a low curved entrance he walks through without hoisting a leg. If your problem is smell, the kind that stays in the plastic no matter what you scrub it with, stainless steel is the honest fix. Neither box is the better box. They answer two different complaints, and it took me a few weeks of using both to see that clearly.

IRIS USA XX-LargeStainless Steel Pan
Floor space30 inches long by 20 wide, 14 inches tallVaries by maker, often smaller and lower
Scatter control14 inch walls with a scatter shield along the back and sidesUsually lower walls, though some makers add a shield
Getting in and out6.5 inch curved entrance, a low step overDepends on the maker, some are a high step
Everyday wipe-downSmooth interior with minimal crevices, wipes out in under a minuteFlat steel wipes clean, but litter cakes into welded corners
Noise at scoop timeQuiet under a plastic scoopRings and clangs under a metal scoop
Odor after a few yearsPlastic can take on smell as it agesDoes not absorb odor at all
Deep sanitizingCareful with hot water and strong cleanersCan be scrubbed hard and scalded
DurabilityPlastic dulls and scratches, no warranty listedResists scratching and cracking
Staying put4.3 pounds, easy to lift, can slide on tileHeavier, stays where you put it
WarrantyNone listedVaries by maker, often none

Where the IRIS USA XX-Large Wins

Start with the measurements, because for a Maine Coon they are the whole argument. Thirty inches long and twenty wide gives Barnaby room to turn around without stepping in what he just did, and I have watched him try to do exactly that in smaller pans, with predictable results. The fourteen inch walls are the part I did not know I needed. He is a tall cat, and when he stands to urinate he clears the rim of an ordinary pan by a couple of inches. Before I bought anything I tried the cheap fix first, which was a clear plastic storage tote from the hardware store with a door cut into one end with a utility knife. It was big, and it was a failure. The cut edge was sharp enough to catch his fur at the shoulder, the sides bowed out when I lifted it half full of litter, and the lid trapped so much ammonia that I could smell the laundry room from the hallway. I gave it three days and then I gave up on it. With the IRIS USA box, the laundry room floor stays dry. That alone changed my mornings.

The entrance is the detail that sold me. A six and a half inch curved opening sounds small until you watch an older, stiff cat use one. Barnaby walks in flat-footed instead of lifting a leg over a wall, and that matters more every year he gets older. The scatter shield along the back and sides catches most of what he kicks, which was the other half of my sweeping problem. The whole box weighs four and a third pounds, light enough that I carry it to the utility sink one-handed on wash day. It is plastic, and I will get to what that costs you in a minute.

A large long-haired tabby cat stepping over the low curved front of a high-sided litter pan on a laundry room floor.

Where Stainless Steel Wins

Here is where I have to be fair to steel. Plastic is porous at a level you cannot see, and over the years it holds onto smell in a way that scrubbing never fully reverses. A stainless steel pan does not absorb anything. If you have ever walked into a room and known the box was there before you saw it, and you had already tried every litter on the shelf, steel addresses the cause instead of covering it. You can hit it with hot water and a strong cleaner without worrying that you are wrecking the surface, and it comes back looking like it did before.

Steel also does not scratch the way plastic does. Scoop a plastic pan twice a day for three years and the bottom goes dull and rough, and rough plastic gives bacteria somewhere to settle in. Stainless takes the same wear and rinses clean. It is heavier too, which cuts both ways. A steel pan stays where you put it when an eighteen pound cat pushes off the rim, and it is a nuisance to lift into the sink, especially if your back is not what it was. And a small thing nobody mentions: a metal scoop on a metal pan rings like a fire alarm at six in the morning.

Thirty inches of floor space and fourteen inches of wall, which is roughly what a cat this size needs

The IRIS USA XX-Large high-sided box gives Barnaby room to turn around and a low curved door he can still walk through at eight years old. That is the whole case for it.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →

What Neither Box Fixes

Neither pan stops tracking. A long-haired cat carries litter out between his toes and in the britches behind his back legs, and taller walls do not change that. What I sweep now is roughly a handful a day, down from two, and the difference came from a mat with a waffle texture at the door and a weekly brush-out, not from a different box. I keep the mat just outside the entrance and shake it into the bin on Sunday mornings before the grandkids come over, and that ten seconds is worth more than any feature on either pan. If the coat behind the back legs starts matting into felt, that is a grooming question and worth asking your vet or a groomer rather than fighting it with a comb at home. Barnaby's ruff and britches mat in about a week if I skip it, and no litter pan on the market solves that for me.

Neither box fixes aim, either. A cat who urinates over the side of a fourteen inch wall is telling you something, and it is usually worth a call to our vet rather than a shopping trip. I say that plainly because I have done the shopping trip first and it was the wrong order of operations. A bigger pan solves the everyday mess of a big cat. It does not solve a medical problem, and it does not solve a cat who has decided he objects to the location of the box.

A laundry room corner with a litter mat on tile, a scoop on a shelf, and folded towels in afternoon light.

A Week With Each One

In daily use the two boxes feel less alike than they look. The IRIS USA box gets scooped twice a day, morning before breakfast and again around seven in the evening, and the smooth interior with its few crevices means a wipe with a paper towel and a mild vinegar solution takes me under a minute. I mix roughly one part white vinegar to three parts water in a spray bottle and keep it under the utility sink, and I use a soft brush rather than anything abrasive on wash day because I do not want to dull the surface myself. The steel pan does the same job with more noise and less lifting trouble on the front end, and a good deal more lifting trouble when I have to haul it to the sink full of soapy water.

Where the steel pan genuinely won me over was on a warm week in July, when the laundry room got stuffy and the plastic box began to smell faintly even after a full wash. The steel one did not. Where the IRIS USA box won was every single morning, when Barnaby walked in without hesitating and the floor stayed clean. By the end of the fortnight I understood that I was not choosing between a good product and a bad one. I was choosing which annoyance I would rather live with.

He can stand up, turn around, and scratch at the far wall without stepping in what he just did. That is the entire review.

The Long Run

Plastic will not last forever. The IRIS USA box lists no warranty, and I would not expect one on a pan in this range. The pan I retired before this one lasted a little over three years of twice-daily scooping before the bottom went dull and rough under my fingers, and once it went rough it held a faint smell that no amount of scrubbing reached. What I expect from this one is the same few years of hard use, the same dulled bottom, and eventually a replacement. For the money that is a fair trade, and it is the reason I did not agonize over the decision. If it goes rough and holds odor in three or four years, I will buy another one and know exactly what I am getting.

A stainless steel pan is the opposite bargain. It outlasts the cat, more or less, and it never develops that sour edge in the plastic. If you are the sort of person who would rather buy one thing and be done, steel is the more sensible purchase and I will not pretend otherwise. My only caution is to look at the measurements before you order. Plenty of steel pans are built for an average cat, and an average cat is not eighteen pounds with a long body and a high opinion of himself.

Who Should Buy Which

Buy the IRIS USA XX-Large if your complaint is size and mess. A big cat, a tall cat, a cat who hangs over the rim, a cat getting stiff in the hips and unwilling to step over a wall. Thirty by twenty inches with a fourteen inch wall and a six and a half inch curved entrance is a sensible shape for a Maine Coon, and the four and a third pound weight means you will actually keep it clean instead of dreading wash day. That is most of the battle, honestly. The box you are willing to scrub is the box that stays fresh.

Buy a stainless steel pan if your complaint is odor, or if you have already been through two plastic boxes and you are tired of replacing them. Check the inside dimensions against your cat before you commit, and check how high the entry is, because a stiff older cat may not thank you for a deep step. Measure him from chest to rump and add a few inches, then compare that to the inside of any pan you are considering. It sounds fussy and it saves a return. If you can only do one thing this month and the smell is what is bothering you, steel first. If the litter on the floor is what is bothering you, the IRIS USA box first. And either way, keep the mat by the door.

If the problem is floor space and a stiff back leg, this is the box that fixes it

Barnaby is eight, eighteen pounds, and not interested in climbing into anything. The IRIS USA XX-Large gave him room to turn around and a door he can still walk through. Same size, same shape, no guesswork.

Check Today's Price on Amazon →